Automatic vs Manual Cars

More and more cars on Irish roads are automatic, thanks in part to the growing use and popularity of EVs and Hybrids. In 2025, there were over 47,000 automatic cars registered in Ireland, according to statistics from SIMI. While automatic cars may seem like the more hassle-free option to get from A to B there is more to consider, such as purchase price, running costs and maintenance.

Running Costs of Automatic Vs Manual Cars

One of the main price differences between automatic and manual cars is the purchase price. Automatic cars typically cost more to buy both used and new, costing an average of €1,000 more than manual cars.

Also, manual cars are usually cheaper to get serviced and typically require less frequent servicing. And when it comes to repairs, automatic cars can also cost more due to more complex parts, such as the automatic gearbox or transmission. 

Emission rates of automatic cars tend to be higher, which means you’ll end up paying more for the road tax on the automatic model. Fuel consumption is also higher in automatic cars. 

The majority of car owners in Ireland drive manual cars. But which is the best option?

Unlike our neighbours in the US, most cars on the road in Ireland are still manual. However, the gap is closing with more and more automatic cars appearing on roads in Ireland each year thanks to the introduction of EVs, hybrids and imports. The majority of new drivers will likely still learn to drive using a manual car. But what is there a difference and what are the benefits? 

Your First Driving Licence 

If you plan on taking the driving test anytime soon, it might be worth noting that if you pass your test driving an automatic car, your licence is restricted to automatic cars only. If you want to switch to driving a manual car at a later date, you’ll have to re-sit your test. However, if you pass your test driving a manual car, you’re entitled to drive either transmission type. 

Driving Experience

Drivers of manual cars benefit from better control (especially in icy conditions). You’ll also notice a higher level of revving which can sound unpleasant on some ranges of automatic cars. However, this is improving with new automatic cars as they now have more gears to switch through to alleviate this.

In terms of comfort, automatic cars offer a smoother ride. An automatic car is often more suitable for frequent traffic drivers, as you do not need to keep changing gears and pressing the clutch if you’re stuck in slow-moving traffic. 

So if you’re looking for a smoother ride requiring less movement, go with the automatic. If you’re looking for a cheaper option which gives you added control, go for the manual.